American Idol Season Finale Eve

I'm watching American Idol and I learned something new!
I never knew a person could say something that was simultaneously non sequitur and redundant!

Paula Abdul regarding Jordin Spark's second song, said, "You look great but you are a great vocal voice."

What?

That's such a strange sentence I don't even know where to begin. Nevermind that it's a non sequitur akin to, "wow, that mango was really juicy but you drive really fast", saying someone is a 'great vocal voice' is not only doesn't make any sense but if it did make sense it would be redundant.

That Paula. What a wacky girl. Annie says she's probably hopped up on pain killers... you know... for her broken nose.